But: が・でも
Sentence 1 が、sentence 2/Sentence 1。でも、sentence 2
Sentence 1 が、sentence 2 = “…, but…”. At the start of a sentence: でも. In relaxed speech: けど.
In short
が between two sentences means “but”: “おいしいですが、高いです” = it's good but expensive. でも does the same at the start of a sentence. Careful: this が follows a complete sentence (です, ます); it isn't the subject particle.
- この 店は おいしいですが、高いです。kono mise wa oishii desu ga, takai desuThis restaurant is good, but expensive.
- 日本語は むずかしいです。でも、おもしろいです。nihongo wa muzukashii desu. demo, omoshiroi desuJapanese is difficult. But it's interesting.
- すみませんが、ペンを かして ください。sumimasen ga, pen o kashite kudasaiExcuse me, could you lend me a pen?
が: but (in the same sentence)
が after a sentence means “but”. It links two opposing ideas in one sentence, followed by a comma. Careful: it's the same character as the subject particle が, but it follows a whole sentence, not a noun.
- 日本語は むずかしいですが、おもしろいです。nihongo wa muzukashii desu ga, omoshiroi desuJapanese is difficult, but interesting.
- 行きたいですが、じかんが ありません。ikitai desu ga, jikan ga arimasenI'd like to go, but I don't have time.
でも: but (at the start of a sentence)
でも starts a new sentence to contrast with the previous one: “…。でも、…”. It's more conversational than が.
- この 店は たかいです。でも、おいしいです。kono mise wa takai desu. demo, oishii desuThis restaurant is expensive. But it's good.
Three ways to say “but”
The meaning is the same; the position and register change.
| Word | Position | Register |
|---|---|---|
| が | between two sentences, before the comma | polite, written and spoken |
| けど | between two sentences | spoken, relaxed |
| でも | at the start of the second sentence | spoken |
Softening a request
が at the end of a clause softens a request or a remark, leaving what follows hanging: すみませんが… (excuse me, but…).
- すみませんが、しゃしんを とって ください。sumimasen ga, shashin o totte kudasaiExcuse me, could you take a photo?
Common mistakes
- Starting a sentence with が: at the start of a sentence, it's でも.
- Confusing this が with the subject particle: “but” follows a whole sentence (ですが, ますが).
- Using けど in careful writing: prefer が.
5 exercises on this point
Particles to choose, sentences to put back in order, translations: marked straight away, then reviewed at the right time. This JLPT N5 point is on the Shinjuku Line (The city) of the Tokyo subway.