KotojutsuStart

Version française

Regretfully unable to: 〜かねる

Verb (stem) + かねる/かねます

Stem + かねる(かねます): “I'm afraid I'm not in a position to”, a refusal or moral impossibility, expressed politely. The customer-service phrase. Not to be confused with かねない (“could well, might”).

In short

〜かねる expresses a polite inability: “I'm afraid I'm not in a position to”. The obstacle isn't physical but moral, social or a matter of rules: you can't, because it wouldn't be appropriate or isn't allowed. It's the phrase of customer service and official replies (お答えしかねます). Careful: かねない (“could well, might”) means almost the opposite.

  • その件については、私からはお答えしかねます。そのけんについては、わたしからはおこたえしかねます。On that matter, I'm afraid I'm not in a position to answer.
  • 申し訳ございませんが、ご要望には応じかねます。もうしわけございませんが、ごようぼうにはおうじかねます。We're very sorry, but we're unable to accommodate your request.
  • 部長の意見には、さすがに賛成しかねる。ぶちょうのいけんには、さすがにさんせいしかねる。I really can't bring myself to agree with the department head's view.
  • 困っている様子を見るに見かねて、声をかけた。こまっているようすをみるにみかねて、こえをかけた。Unable to stand by any longer watching him struggle, I went over and spoke to him.

The basics

かねる originally means “to find it hard to, to be unable to bring oneself to”. Attached to a verb stem, it says you can't do something, not for lack of ability, but because rules, your position or morals prevent it. So it's never “I can't swim”: it's “I'm not in a position to, I can't bring myself to”.

In service settings, it's the tool of polite refusal: instead of a blunt できません, staff say いたしかねます, “I'm afraid we're unable to”. The regret is built into the form.

The sentence, piece by piece
その件についてはon that matter (topic)
私からはfrom me
お答えしanswer (humble, stem)
かねますbe unable to (polite)

On that matter, I'm afraid I'm not in a position to answer.

  • noun
  • verb
  • grammatical form
  • こちらの商品は、返品をお受けいたしかねます。こちらのしょうひんは、へんぴんをおうけいたしかねます。I'm afraid we're unable to accept returns on this item.
  • お電話では、詳しいご案内はいたしかねます。おでんわでは、くわしいごあんないはいたしかねます。We're not able to give you full details over the phone.

How to form it

Take the verb stem (the ます-form without ます) and add かねる, which conjugates like a る-verb. In service settings, it nearly always attaches to a humble form: お答えする → お答えしかねます, いたす → いたしかねます.

FormExampleUse
stem + かねる賛成しかねるwritten, personal opinion
stem + かねますお答えしかねますpolite refusal, customer service
いたしかねますご案内いたしかねますvery formal refusal
stem + かねている決めかねているto hesitate, can't manage to
見るに見かねて見るに見かねて手伝ったunable to bear watching any longer
  • その考えには、どうしても同意しかねる。そのかんがえには、どうしてもどういしかねる。I really can't go along with that idea.
  • 引っ越すかどうか、まだ決めかねている。ひっこすかどうか、まだきめかねている。I still can't decide whether to move or not.

かねる versus できません

できません is clear but curt: it states an impossibility. かねます wraps it in apology: we'd like to, but we can't. In a shop, a hotel or a bank, it's the expected form.

On the other hand, かねる isn't used for a physical inability or a skill: “泳ぎかねる” (can't swim) is wrong. You say 泳げない.

SentenceTone
それはできません。direct, curt
それはちょっと…。evasive, spoken
それはいたしかねます。polite, professional refusal
  • 子どもは三歳なので、まだ泳げない。こどもはさんさいなので、まだおよげない。My child is three, so they can't swim yet. (ability: no かねる)
  • 個人情報のため、お教えしかねます。こじんじょうほうのため、おおしえしかねます。As it's personal information, we're unable to share it with you.

かねる, かねない: two opposite meanings

かねない (N2, line 5), in the negative form, doesn't mean “can” but “could well, risks”: an unfortunate consequence is possible. So it isn't the logical opposite of かねる; it's a different tool.

A trick to avoid mistakes: かねる (affirmative) = I can't; かねない (negative) = it could well happen.

  • スピードを出しすぎると、事故を起こしかねない。すぴーどをだしすぎると、じこをおこしかねない。If you drive too fast, you could cause an accident.
  • その日はご予約をお受けしかねます。そのひはごよやくをおうけしかねます。We're unable to take bookings that day.

Common mistakes

  • Reading かねます as “I can”: it's a refusal. お答えしかねます = “I can't answer”.
  • Using it for a physical inability: “泳ぎかねる” is wrong; you say 泳げない.
  • Mixing up かねる (politely unable) and かねない (could well): the negative doesn't translate as “can”.

7 exercises on this point

Particles to choose, sentences to put back in order, translations: marked straight away, then reviewed at the right time. This JLPT N2 point is on the Higashiyama Line (The working world) of the Nagoya lines.