Regretfully unable to: 〜かねる
Verb (stem) + かねる/かねます
Stem + かねる(かねます): “I'm afraid I'm not in a position to”, a refusal or moral impossibility, expressed politely. The customer-service phrase. Not to be confused with かねない (“could well, might”).
In short
〜かねる expresses a polite inability: “I'm afraid I'm not in a position to”. The obstacle isn't physical but moral, social or a matter of rules: you can't, because it wouldn't be appropriate or isn't allowed. It's the phrase of customer service and official replies (お答えしかねます). Careful: かねない (“could well, might”) means almost the opposite.
- その件については、私からはお答えしかねます。そのけんについては、わたしからはおこたえしかねます。On that matter, I'm afraid I'm not in a position to answer.
- 申し訳ございませんが、ご要望には応じかねます。もうしわけございませんが、ごようぼうにはおうじかねます。We're very sorry, but we're unable to accommodate your request.
- 部長の意見には、さすがに賛成しかねる。ぶちょうのいけんには、さすがにさんせいしかねる。I really can't bring myself to agree with the department head's view.
- 困っている様子を見るに見かねて、声をかけた。こまっているようすをみるにみかねて、こえをかけた。Unable to stand by any longer watching him struggle, I went over and spoke to him.
The basics
かねる originally means “to find it hard to, to be unable to bring oneself to”. Attached to a verb stem, it says you can't do something, not for lack of ability, but because rules, your position or morals prevent it. So it's never “I can't swim”: it's “I'm not in a position to, I can't bring myself to”.
In service settings, it's the tool of polite refusal: instead of a blunt できません, staff say いたしかねます, “I'm afraid we're unable to”. The regret is built into the form.
On that matter, I'm afraid I'm not in a position to answer.
- noun
- verb
- grammatical form
- こちらの商品は、返品をお受けいたしかねます。こちらのしょうひんは、へんぴんをおうけいたしかねます。I'm afraid we're unable to accept returns on this item.
- お電話では、詳しいご案内はいたしかねます。おでんわでは、くわしいごあんないはいたしかねます。We're not able to give you full details over the phone.
How to form it
Take the verb stem (the ます-form without ます) and add かねる, which conjugates like a る-verb. In service settings, it nearly always attaches to a humble form: お答えする → お答えしかねます, いたす → いたしかねます.
| Form | Example | Use |
|---|---|---|
| stem + かねる | 賛成しかねる | written, personal opinion |
| stem + かねます | お答えしかねます | polite refusal, customer service |
| いたしかねます | ご案内いたしかねます | very formal refusal |
| stem + かねている | 決めかねている | to hesitate, can't manage to |
| 見るに見かねて | 見るに見かねて手伝った | unable to bear watching any longer |
- その考えには、どうしても同意しかねる。そのかんがえには、どうしてもどういしかねる。I really can't go along with that idea.
- 引っ越すかどうか、まだ決めかねている。ひっこすかどうか、まだきめかねている。I still can't decide whether to move or not.
かねる versus できません
できません is clear but curt: it states an impossibility. かねます wraps it in apology: we'd like to, but we can't. In a shop, a hotel or a bank, it's the expected form.
On the other hand, かねる isn't used for a physical inability or a skill: “泳ぎかねる” (can't swim) is wrong. You say 泳げない.
| Sentence | Tone |
|---|---|
| それはできません。 | direct, curt |
| それはちょっと…。 | evasive, spoken |
| それはいたしかねます。 | polite, professional refusal |
- 子どもは三歳なので、まだ泳げない。こどもはさんさいなので、まだおよげない。My child is three, so they can't swim yet. (ability: no かねる)
- 個人情報のため、お教えしかねます。こじんじょうほうのため、おおしえしかねます。As it's personal information, we're unable to share it with you.
かねる, かねない: two opposite meanings
かねない (N2, line 5), in the negative form, doesn't mean “can” but “could well, risks”: an unfortunate consequence is possible. So it isn't the logical opposite of かねる; it's a different tool.
A trick to avoid mistakes: かねる (affirmative) = I can't; かねない (negative) = it could well happen.
- スピードを出しすぎると、事故を起こしかねない。すぴーどをだしすぎると、じこをおこしかねない。If you drive too fast, you could cause an accident.
- その日はご予約をお受けしかねます。そのひはごよやくをおうけしかねます。We're unable to take bookings that day.
Common mistakes
- Reading かねます as “I can”: it's a refusal. お答えしかねます = “I can't answer”.
- Using it for a physical inability: “泳ぎかねる” is wrong; you say 泳げない.
- Mixing up かねる (politely unable) and かねない (could well): the negative doesn't translate as “can”.
7 exercises on this point
Particles to choose, sentences to put back in order, translations: marked straight away, then reviewed at the right time. This JLPT N2 point is on the Higashiyama Line (The working world) of the Nagoya lines.